The first roguelike of the collection so far, though we'll start to see many many more before too long, and another where the Steam play time is misleading. I've played various version of The Binding of Isaac far more than this, the slightly-janky Flash original. Specifically the 3DS and Nintendo Switch releases.
I don't really love it though. I like it well enough. I enjoy roguelikes, I enjoy games that let you build strange and unlikely synergies of powerups and weapons, I enjoy arena-shooters. But I'm not thirteen years old and Edmund McMillen's "peepee-and-poopoo are funny and also religion is bad and I'm dark and edgy" thing doesn't really land with me.
Would I play it again? This Flash version with keyboard-only controls and 30fps cap? Nah. In fact I don't even know why it's still for sale as its own thing in parallel with the remaster. Why not just bundle it in with Rebirth so that the curious can see where it came from and people don't buy it by accident then wonder why this oft-praised game is so thin?
Before Meat Boy and Isaac et al, Edmund McMillen first gained some attention with puzzle-platformer Gish. It's mostly pretty standard get-to-the-exit without dying stuff, not a million miles away from yesterday's game Blocks That Matter. The gimmick here being that your character is an amorphous blob of tar with a cartoon face, who can squeeze through gaps, stick to walls, etc.
It's a technically clever trick but I can't say I found it particularly enjoyable to play. Perhaps as an inevitable outcome of controlling a squishy semi-solid blob, the controls feel imprecise and fiddly. On top of which the level design is pretty uninspired and often results in deaths that feel unfair, or in some cases your blobby hero just getting outright stuck. The way the stages just seem to end when you reach a certain point without any obvious exit or finish line makes the whole thing seem unpolished. Because it's almost the exact opposite of Super Meat Boy - a game feted for its super-tight controls and level design - it's tempting to imagine the latter being a direct response to this game's failings.
Would I play it again? No, I would not.
![]()